Seth Russell

 Ohio Dominican University

Football 

2018 

 Luke Shively

 Otterbein University

 Wrestling

2018

 Dimitri Williams

Cleveland State University 

Wrestling 

 2017

Blake Darnell 

Tiffin University 

Football 

2016 

Tanner Walker 

Muskingum University 

Wrestling 

2016

 Kameron Bowen

Wheeling Jesuit University 

Track & Field 

2018 

 Wyatt Saxton

Marietta College 

 Track & Field

 2018

 Bailey Harris

 Muskingum University 

Softball 

2018